Point system for Team Melli performance.

[maij]

I have suggested a Point system for Team Melli performance. to rank players and coaches.

If you wish to contribute to enhance the system or improve it , If you believe that you have ideas that are worth considering or debating , I appreciate your feedback in the following Post.

Read the instructions carefully and then post your feedback.
I kindly advise you not to hijack the post for any other arguments of for individual players status.

Thanks.

[Doctor DOOM]

very good system Majid jan.
however, the factor of "quality of the opposition" has to be taken into account.

Iran winning japan 1-0 shd carry more points than 1-0 defeat of lebanon.

Now, the easiest way to put a number to it is the fifa ranking the teams hold. Japan's ranking higher therefore more points.

how to score, then? I can only guess and this is open to debate.
say team X is 57th in the world. and it defeats 34th team.
apart from the points you have mentioned above, we add more points for the fact that it was a HIGHER ranked team.

but then team X plays 19th team and wins. certainly it shd get more points than the game against 34th.

we can divide the teams ABOVE the team x in fifa ranking by every 10 team.
hence team x ( 57th ) will have 5 groups of 10 team each ABOVE it.
- for winning teams within its group , 51-60, team x gets no points.
- for teams 41-50, X gets 1 point extra. ( or you can make it 2. up to you )
- for teams 31-40, X gets 2 ( or perhaps 3 or 4 ) extra points.
- for teams 21-30 , X gets 3 ( or 4 or 6 ) extra points
- for teams 11-20 , X gets 4 ( or 5 or 8 ) extra p's.
- for teams 1-10, X gets 5 ( or 6 or 10 ) extra points.

once we set the the immediately higher group's points ( Base of 1 or 2 points ), we can either ADD for every group of higher rankings or multiply by 2. up to you.

so if a team ranked 123rd beats the 8th ranked team, they get ( LOOLL ) .... sh*tload of points . But I say they well deserve it. how often do we see such a game with such a disparity ? so even if the points are too much, I say the feat itself is worthy of the points.


for DRAWS, I'd say we stick to a base of 1 point and add 1 extra for every group ( of 10 teams above that ).
for defeating a lower ranked team, we just shrug and give them a cold shoulder and not add. tell the team "what? felan-e ghool ro shikoondi?"



for defeats to lower ranked teams, shd we punish the team with higher ranking?
I'd say deduction of 1 point per group ( of 10 teams ).
cheshmeshoon koor. dandeshoon narm. ta digeh injoori gherti baazi dar nayarand, Shol-o-vel baazi konan!!

----------------------------------------
----------------------------------------
same with continents.
winning a european team shd carry more weight than an asia on one from oceania or even north/central america.
I guess based on fifa rankings and general sense, europe shd hold first place, followed closely by south america, then africa, then north/central americas, asia and finally oceania. altho I'd say asia = north/central americas.

ranking could be:
1- europe
2- South america
3- africa
joint 4- asia & north/central americas
5- oceania

if new zealand beats a south american team, we add +3 ( or 6, double the difference in ranking ) .
or if Fiji beats england, we add +4 ( or 8, double the difference in ranking ) ( and I personally will add 100 to any team beating england and Italy )


same thing for Draws. add +1 for every higher category.
0 for the same category.



for defeats to lower ranked teams, shd we punish the team with higher ranking?
I'd say deduction of 1 point per group.

[perspolees]

I have suggested a Point system for Team Melli performance. to rank players and coaches.

If you wish to contribute to enhance the system or improve it , If you believe that you have ideas that are worth considering or debating , I appreciate your feedback in the following Post.

Read the instructions carefully and then post your feedback.
I kindly advise you not to hijack the post for any other arguments of for individual players status.

Thanks.

good idea. this is one of those already done things by the advanced footballing nations. Maybe you could tell us how they do it?

[Doctor DOOM]

for example, today's game against syria can have plenty of data to quantify.
loosely based on this :
http://www.persianfootball.com/forum...72&postcount=2
I will just go over the basic points allotments although a lot of other categories and factors have been mentioned in this thread that can be added to complete the overall picture.


TEAM category- we played with an asian ( continental points ) team, ranked XX ( ranking points ), at home ( venue points ), with score of 0-0 ( results points ), in a WCQ game ( competition points ) .

COACH category - coach was EZ ( coaching points ), getting a draw ( result points ) at home ( venue points ), in his third match as the coach ( tenure points ), played with an asian ( continental points ) team, ranked XX ( ranking points ), in a WCQ game ( competition points ) .



PLAYER category- players played will receive their points ( caps points ). starters and subs receive corresponding points.
plus they receive the result points for the game as well.


and we can add a few other data to the above set and get a more realistic view on the game.