Foreign or national coach ?!

[maij]

Bahram jan... You really managed to confuse this poor soul

You mention that Football is not rocket science , yet you go on about the career of western coaches compared to Iranian and leading me to believe that Iranians will never reach the standard of a European coach !

You say that you have culturally learned a lot from being an Iranian from outside hence leading me to think that you are NOT the typical Iranian, but then you follow the classical and Iranian party line with your " Ein Kharijiyeh ...class dareh" mentality !!! glorifying anything foreign , ridiculing anything national or local !

I can't figure out what is next , Bahram Agha.

The reason that I posted that news was to indicate to many out there that classes , courses , seminars and workshops are held regularly in Iran despite the beleif of some that the country has no football education/ training system for coaches. I did NOT suggest that this one day class will breed champions and gradute Phd in soccer science!

However , since you mentioned the career development of a western coach , how about one Mr. Jurgen Klinsmann ?

BTW: I have a long list of Western coaches who have NOT followed what you suggested , but will start with Klinsmann to see how you can justify his case initially.

[zzgloo]

Bahram jan... You really managed to confuse this poor soul

You mention that Football is not rocket science , yet you go on about the career of western coaches compared to Iranian and leading me to believe that Iranians will never reach the standard of a European coach !

You say that you have culturally learned a lot from being an Iranian from outside hence leading me to think that you are NOT the typical Iranian, but then you follow the classical and Iranian party line with your " Ein Kharijiyeh ...class dareh" mentality !!! glorifying anything foreign , ridiculing anything national or local !

I can't figure out what is next , Bahram Agha.

The reason that I posted that news was to indicate to many out there that classes , courses , seminars and workshops are held regularly in Iran despite the beleif of some that the country has no football education/ training system for coaches. I did NOT suggest that this one day class will breed champions and gradute Phd in soccer science!

However , since you mentioned the career development of a western coach , how about one Mr. Jurgen Klinsmann ?

BTW: I have a long list of Western coaches who have NOT followed what you suggested , but will start with Klinsmann to see how you can justify his case initially.

Majid e aziz...
I must have given contradicting signals,...but I did not mean to....,yet,you , an intelegent reader,must have seen something...

These are points I have raised in my posts,in different threads ,and I personaly do not see any inconsistancies in them :if you do, please point them to me:

1- Football is not a Rocket science, It only requires,players with basic skills,and organization.

2-In order for players to learn basic skills and organization,they must be taught, that is they must be going through some "teachings".

3-coaches in IRAN, do not know the basics of coaching,which is " Teaching ".

4-coaches in Iran,lack knowledge themseleves....( I mentioned why,in my previouse posts )

5-the process of becoming a coach is very elementary in IRAN ,and competition among coaches is non-existant.( I explained before )

6-A new class of coaches is required, with background of playing and learning coaching in Europe,...such as, Mahdavikia,hashemian,etc...such remedy has proven fruitful in Business.
.................................................. .................................................. ..

To answer your specific points :

1-Iranian coaches will some day get to the level of good forign coaches, when, the level of competition is high among domestic coaches, and all are equiped with today's knowledge of football.....this will happen, when we get to the secound class of " New generation of coaches ".when the knowledge is sufficiently transfered and passed around.

2- Klinsman, or maradona,or beckenbauer,or Ali Daei,etc.......these individuals,became coaches on the count of popularity....and are exceptional cases,and the results of those kind of coaches have been mixed.......yet a country can not base the future of its football on exceptions.


.