Beiranvand's Performance Against Qatar

[FootballeKhob]

Honestly, I feel like Amir Abedzadeh deserves another chance. IMO he was amazing. Check out this save, would any other current TM goali be able to do that? Note how far that first shot was, and how much he had to stretch, yet he still managed to do (now compare this to Beiros performance on the 3rd Qatar goal...)

Amir had one weak moment against Korea, that cost him his position it seems. (I don't count that strange Algeria game, as pretty much every single TM player was horrible that day).
Meanwhile, Beiro is having bad moments at least once in every single game since WC2018. I was a huge fan of Beiro. Still am, but he should have been replaced years ago imo. If Abedzadeh is not viable, I'd prefer Niazmand. Either way, Beiro must go imo.

Just cause Beiro needs to be changed doesnt mean a very very overrated abdezadeh who really couldnt make it in IPL should get another chance. He makes more sootis than beiro and the only good thing about him is being good on the ball.

[Kojiro Hyuga]

He (Abedzadeh) had a howler of a sooti in his new club just a few months ago.

lol you mean the one where he stops playing and lifts his hand cause he thought the ball was out and then he gets scored on? xD Yea I saw that too...

Just cause Beiro needs to be changed doesnt mean a very very overrated abdezadeh who really couldnt make it in IPL should get another chance. He makes more sootis than beiro and the only good thing about him is being good on the ball.

Honestly, I didn't follow much of Amirs club performance, so you are probably much more knowledgable on that than me. But from what I could tell, he was fairly consistent, had plenty of clean sheets and was playing in Portugal/Spain. Even the second tier Spanish pro league is worth more and way above what the IPL can produce imho.
As for Amirs TM performance, as I mentioned, I think he only had one weak moment, which was the goal he got scored on against SK. Other than that (and even in that same game) he was pretty good. So I don't know how that justifies to sideline him, while Beiro has been inconsistent for years...

[roozan]

id rather have niazmand than beiro and thats saying something

[perspolis#1]

Part of the GK discussion needs to be about how they coordinate with the defense.

Having an imposing GK with great positioning is great if we are a defensive team that will face few shots. Especially if we have some "ghool" defenders who are more physical then technical and will be getting stuck in. When your defense is competent enough to never be out of position and allow few chances it works. If we had this scenario. Maybe 3-4 shots against our goalie a game.

If we have a defense that is more fluid, less imposing but better on the ball, a distributing shotstopping goalkeeper is better. If we had a GK that could distibute the way Allison, Ederson, Onana do our defenders need to also be capable of passing on the ground also. The best defense would be not giving the other team the ball.

If we have a disconnect it leads to problems. Beiranvand can try to distribute nonchalantly but if our defenders are weak when facing our own goal when getting the ball it will be dangerous either way. This happened a few times last Asian cup. In that case it would be better if he blasted it far.

A lot of teams succeed or fail on this concept. Look at how disastrous Manchester United's defense was when they tried to pass out the back but De Gea couldnt causing turnovers.

In our scenario, having two slow defenders with Rezaian often halfway up the field and Mohammadi unable to trap a pass makes it a landmine for mistakes/disaster.