Referee mistakes PGL 2014-2105!

[shahname]

[Abtin]

Wasn't that the referee from Iran who was 4th referee in many WC matches?

[rugs]

Then you will have to answer some physics questions.

How is it possible that the ball bounced directly back in the direction it came while Khalatbari's hand was going up and Heydari's hand was moving in the same direction the ball bounced.



Ball
<--------------

Heydari's hand
<--------------

Khalatbari's Hand
^
|
|
|
|

[Abtin]

Look at 2:47: you can see Khalatbaris hand moving upwards, wheres as Heydaris hand moving towards the ball, hence him boxing the ball away making it bounce back: http://footballitarin.com/video_page.php?id=11621
Good and fair call by Faghani!

[shahname]

Ok I have watched the seen several times again and it is still difficult to see who touches the ball, khalatbari or Heydari. But I can see what you guys mean and maybe it was in fact a correct call.

[saadat_abad]

the ball infact touches khalatbaris arm first then heydari makes contact with it. tough call. to be honet it was a 50 50 call. you can say yes it was on purpose and you can also say it was accidental. in my opinion 50 50 call. the ref obviously went for the safest option

[kia]

Joke of the day:
خسرو حیدری : ناخنم به توپ خورد و داور پنالتی گرفت
Khosro Heydari:
The ball hit my fingernail & the ref called a handball.

[unique football]

Joke of the day:
خسرو حیدری : ناخنم به توپ خورد و داور پنالتی گرفت
Khosro Heydari:
The ball hit my fingernail & the ref called a handball.

[unique football]

the ball infact touches khalatbaris arm first then heydari makes contact with it. tough call. to be honet it was a 50 50 call. you can say yes it was on purpose and you can also say it was accidental. in my opinion 50 50 call. the ref obviously went for the safest option

stop and play it u will clearly see it was close to touch kb arm but heydari punched it away .

[saadat_abad]

stop and play it u will clearly see it was close to touch kb arm but heydari punched it away .

i did aziz, you can clearly see it skinned kbs arm and was redirected to heydaris arm. 50 50

[unique football]

i did aziz, you can clearly see it skinned kbs arm and was redirected to heydaris arm. 50 50

well aziz man harchi didam be hichja kb nakhord . if you stop at 2:50 it seems it hit his knee first hes moving his left arm backward if you look closely but again its really difficult to say i agree, but again if it did touch its arm the ball would not gone upward and then hit heydaris hand

[saadat_abad]

well aziz man harchi didam be hichja kb nakhord . if you stop at 2:50 it seems it hit his knee first hes moving his left arm backward if you look closely but again its really difficult to say i agree, but again if it did touch its arm the ball would not gone upward and then hit heydaris hand

i know what ur talking about and most of the times when it hits a players arm the ball would not go upwards but in this case it barely skinned kbs arm.. it touched it but it didnt have an impact on the ball. so the ball did hit kbs arm that should have been a freekick for esteghlal ! before it his heydaris hand!

[rugs]

i know what ur talking about and most of the times when it hits a players arm the ball would not go upwards but in this case it barely skinned kbs arm.. it touched it but it didnt have an impact on the ball. so the ball did hit kbs arm that should have been a freekick for esteghlal ! before it his heydaris hand!

But also remember that if a player's hand is in a natural position and the ball hits it, it is not a handball. But if the player's hand is in an unnatural position, regardless of intent, and the ball hits it, it is a handball.

So one must ask, what was Heydari's hand doing in KB's armpit?

I think the last Navad of last season had a great show on handballs and I believe Faghani was the guest for that segment.

[KeonKish]

definitely a handball, but a weird one. Heydaris hand was on KB therefore not in a natural position.

it wouldnt have mattered, esteghlals defense without sadeghi and omranzadeh is a joke. The only positive from todays game was that beautiful shot from fakhredini. Sepahans team is coming together just like I thought they would, they will certainly win the league with such talented attacking players. Navidkia, Sukaj, KB, Pereira, Hajsafi, Sharifi.

[saadat_abad]

But also remember that if a player's hand is in a natural position and the ball hits it, it is not a handball. But if the player's hand is in an unnatural position, regardless of intent, and the ball hits it, it is a handball.

So one must ask, what was Heydari's hand doing in KB's armpit?

I think the last Navad of last season had a great show on handballs and I believe Faghani was the guest for that segment.

you got a good point ! i think he was trying for the little nudge on the back! navad should be good this weekend!!