Vingada or Kranjcar?

[Team Melli Fan]

Pick.

[kia]

Zlat rules.

[Ghomarbaaz]

OMG! is there really a question which one is more qualified?
lol

[sedee91]

Kranjcar qualifies as a top coach anytime with his CV.

[Ghermez Agha]

Faghat kranjcar

[Adesor Vafaseya]

lets do a PROS and CONS here

Aghayeh Vingada:

PROS: has a moustache, looks Irooni, seems to be in his heart Perspolisi.
CONS: didnt win the Olympic Games with Iran yet, which is a big NO NO

Aghayeh Kranjcar:

PROS: comes from Croatia and therefore Aryan orgin, hence a true Iranian. Always clean shaved and well manared (thanks to his origin),
is the SARVAR of GHALENOIE (hehehehe)
CONS: Doesn't wear a moustache, has not won any FIFA World Cup yet in his resumee.



evalauating the above PROS and CONS, I say we deserve better than both of them and request IFF to hire Aleejenaab Aghayeh JORGI LOW asap, so we win the Olympic Games and afterwards the World Cup that we desereve soo badly. Then we sack him just for the sake of it!

[OFFSIDE_1]

there is more to it than just looking at each coach's CV. The TM-U22 team has to work closely with CQ. Kranjkar and CQ have had their differences in the past. Not sure if those two would cooperate with each other

[rezabmehr]

Even though Hashemian has had his issues with CQ, I like to see him in action with some fresh ideas. He certainly has the experience as a player and has been grooming himself to coach at a higher level. This would be a great platform for him to show what he can do IMO.

[mistermo]

I say keep Vingada as head coach. We need stability.

[Paradigm]

there is more to it than just looking at each coach's CV. The TM-U22 team has to work closely with CQ. Kranjkar and CQ have had their differences in the past. Not sure if those two would cooperate with each other

I don't think it is necessary that the senior team and U-23 have to work closely. Competition between the two can force both managers and players to try and get better results. It's like having Lockheed-Martin and General Dynamics present their best to vie for government contracts and develop the latest sea-combat systems.

[pres80]

Even though Hashemian has had his issues with CQ, I like to see him in action with some fresh ideas. He certainly has the experience as a player and has been grooming himself to coach at a higher level. This would be a great platform for him to show what he can do IMO.

What problems has Hashemian had with CQ?

[Salar]

Vingada has a good CV but has failed miserably with the u23s, he hasn't won a single official match. Sometimes it just doesn't work out for certain coaches and I think he should be replaced. IFF seems to be after an Iranian coach and based on what Taj said last night, I believe that Mansourian will be reappointed in the next few days

[Bi-honar]

I don't understand, what does Kranjcar have in his resume that Faraki doesn't? Didn't Faraki have an 80% ratio when he was in charge of the U-23 team?!

[Salar]

I don't understand, what does Kranjcar have in his resume that Faraki doesn't? Didn't Faraki have an 80% ratio when he was in charge of the U-23 team?!

Its unlikely in my opinion for Faraki to leave his post at Sepahan and I genuinely believe that he feels that he's too good for the u23s, whereas I believe Mansourian will take the job if he was offered it and on top of that everyone knows that CQ has a good relationship with him. Taj said that the federation wants to appoint an Iranian coach and I think Mansourian will be reappointed in the upcoming days

[BacheLot]

I've always rated &still prefer Mansurian..!! he is certainly one of the most promising domestic coaches, he is tactically apt and his team play a very attractive, effective football and he has good working relations with CQ and well-experienced at Omid levels knows the strength and talents of all the weapons at his disposal..!
he is still not a finished product as a head coach but he is by far the best domestic option for this job ..!

Zlatco is certainly qualified for the job but he would need complete autonomy to do this work..!! he likely wouldn't accept CQ looking over his shoulder and considering the rift between the two its best for IFF to avoid him..! or if they give him the job, then leave him completely in charge, and reduce CQ's influence in his team..!!