Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Several teams enraged by refereeing at Asian Cup

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Several teams enraged by refereeing at Asian Cup

    Thought this one deserved its own thread, since I'm sure there will more discussions on bad referring going forward!


    Several teams enraged by refereeing at Asian Cup


    January 13th, 2015
    Rappler.com / AFP

    Iran, Oman and holders Japan all raged at the officials after their opening games - not the start Asian officials were hoping for after a determined drive to improve refereeing standards



    MELBOURNE, Australia - As the big guns flex their muscles at the Asian Cup, refereeing controversies are leaving players and coaches hopping mad with the tournament barely five days old.

    Iran, Oman and holders Japan all raged at the officials after their opening games - not the start Asian officials were hoping for after a determined drive to improve refereeing standards.

    Iran coach Carlos Queiroz launched a withering attack on referee Ben Williams, accusing him of failing to keep a lid on Bahrain's "dangerous" tackling in Team Melli's 2-0 win at the weekend and claiming the Australian was out of his depth, despite the fact he officiated at last year's World Cup.

    The red mist descended on Oman coach Paul Le Guen 24 hours earlier after the Gulf side were denied what appeared a nailed-on penalty in a 1-0 defeat by South Korea.

    And Japan's spiky playmaker Keisuke Honda took aim at the man in the middle after Japan's 4-0 win over Palestine, asking whether Qatar's Abdulrahman Hussain had been refereeing a basketball game in comments dripping with sarcasm.

    Despite the efforts of the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) to raise standards, Asian refereeing came under the spotlight at the 2014 World Cup when Japanese referee Yuichi Nishimura awarded hosts Brazil a soft penalty in the opening game, triggering fury from opponents Croatia and lighting up social media.

    Queiroz's ire centred on Bahrain's Faouzi Aaish, the team's snarling forward. "He tried to elbow my players," the former Real Madrid coach told AFP. "As you know elbowing is dangerous. The laws of the game are clear. (The referee) didn't give a single yellow. The referee was not at the level of the game."

    'Rottweiler' bite

    Portugal's Queiroz, nicknamed "Rottweiler" by former Manchester United manager Alex Ferguson during two spells as his assistant coach, took a more conciliatory line over two poor offside decisions which denied Iran two more goals, shrugging: "On the technical side, we all make mistakes."

    Le Guen appeared to have genuine reason to feel aggrieved after New Zealand official Peter O'Leary waved away appeals when Oman striker Qasim Saeed was clattered inside the box. "I ask for equity," fumed the Frenchman. "It's 100 percent a penalty, no hesitation. But (it's not given) because of what? Because we are Oman?"

    Honda's gripe was less clear, however, as five yellow cards and a red were dished out for Palestine's rather agricultural tackling. "It was like a basketball game," sniped Honda. "As soon as we made contact with them, the referee blew the whistle. They need to do something about the level of refereeing here."

    But an AFC spokesman told AFP: "We are happy with the refereeing and happy that they (referees) have sufficient experience, including the World Cup."

    Despite the rumpus, South Korea coach Uli Stielike claimed, perhaps predictably, to be mystified at Le Guen's comments. "I saw the game like the referee saw it," said the German. "I don't know which situation he is talking about. There cannot be a clear penalty or I would remember the situation."



    Jordan's goalkeeper Amer Shafi argues with a Saudi referee during an Asian Cup match with Iraq. Photo by Saeed Khan/AFP


    #2
    They are taking a page from World Cup '14 refereeing... No surprises there.
    sigpic

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Footbal...he_Asian_Games

    Comment


      #3
      that Saudi ref in iraq and jordan game, sucked ass..!! he made sooo many bizarre calls..!!

      our games linesmen's as well missed a couple close offside calls, one diffidently was not an offside ..!

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by BacheLot View Post
        that Saudi ref in iraq and jordan game, sucked ass..!! he made sooo many bizarre calls..!!

        our games linesmen's as well missed a couple close offside calls, one diffidently was not an offside ..!
        He missed 2 - both would have been easy conversions.

        Comment


          #5
          i agree with CQ, we scored two goals and were not offise and were not given super anoying

          Comment


            #6
            The offside calls were actually really close guys - I reviewed the whole tape of the game. There was probably only one that I wouldn't have called as a linesman which I believe was Shojaei with the nice pass to Gucci for an easy tap in.

            But my bigger concern (and apparently CQ's) is the number of fouls the buggers got away with or for which they didn't get yellow cards. Dashtan bacheha ro dero mikardan hamash!

            Hopefully Irmatov will be more strict in the game against Qatar. There were a total of 29 fouls in the 1st game he officiated (Australia-Kuwait) and he handed out only 2 yellow card. In contrast, there were 35 fouls in the Iran-Bahrain game, with only 1 yellow handed out (related to the fouls).

            Comment


              #7
              We've seen much worse officiating ..... I would not consider the aussie ref to make the bottom 10 list.

              I would say the Referee for the Iran-Argentina game was by far worse.

              A missed penalty ....
              Missed fouls .....
              Missed yellow card for a phreakin player removing the corner flag and throwing it down on the pitch .... now how do you miss that one, I really don't know
              “It is easier to fool the people, than to convince them they have been fooled." - Mark Twain

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by OFFSIDE_1 View Post
                Missed yellow card for a phreakin player removing the corner flag and throwing it down on the pitch .... now how do you miss that one, I really don't know
                oh, he didn't miss it.. don't you remember? he promptly went and picked it up and planted it back in its nice little hole.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by teammelli8080 View Post
                  oh, he didn't miss it.. don't you remember? he promptly went and picked it up and planted it back in its nice little hole.
                  the only explanation I have for that move is that the ref had a man crush on the Argentinian players.
                  “It is easier to fool the people, than to convince them they have been fooled." - Mark Twain

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by OFFSIDE_1 View Post
                    the only explanation I have for that move is that the ref had a man crush on the Argentinian players.
                    The bottom line is that he did not want to be the ref that caused Argentina to lose to The Axis Of Evil in Iran.

                    It was actually saddening to watch that match and to see that the ref was genuinely scared to call anything against Argentina.

                    He was intimidated and Iran and its people were made to suffer for it. I will never EVER believe he missed that penalty or didnt give the yellows that were deserved cause he honestly missed them.

                    In the 90th minute I actually had to sit down cause I was shaking so hard and my heart was beating so fast......"Was this the moment Iran will draw against the might of Argentina?" "Was this about to be our greatest sporting moment EVER?"

                    Ahh anyway.. Thats all in the past. Bring on Qatar.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X