Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Should FIFA temporarily ban Iran for not allowing women into stadiums?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Should FIFA temporarily ban Iran for not allowing women into stadiums?

    Indonesia was kicked out of the 2018 World Cup qualifiers for governmental interference. Do you think our federation should receive a ban from international competition for not allowing women into stadiums? I'm curious to know how many of you support women's rights.

    http://www.theguardian.com/world/ira...tball-iran-ban

    'Fifa must tackle Iran's ban on women watching football'

    With the Women’s World Cup final ahead, the soccer world must call for an end to the Islamic republic’s law against women going to stadiums, say prominent human rights activists

    Nasrin Sotoudeh, Nazanin Afshin-Jam MacKay and Gissou Nia for Tehran Bureau
    Friday 3 July 2015 11.58 EDT

    Players from Iran’s women national football team exchange flowers with players from Germany’s Al-Dersimspor team before a friendly match at Tehran’s Ararat stadium, 28 April 2006. Women football fans are prevented from attending stadium games in the Islamic Republic. Photograph: STR/AFP/Getty Images

    As the world watches Sunday’s Women’s World Cup final, TV cameras will capture the joyful faces of spectators of all ages, races, and genders. Such joy, taken for granted by many people around the world, is unfortunately denied to women in Iran.

    Since 1982, the Islamic republic has prohibited women from attending football and other sporting events. Though such discrimination is a blatant violation of the statutes and guiding principles of Fifa, it has counted the Islamic republic of Iran football federation as a member for over 30 years without the slightest reproach. The time has come for the world to call on Fifa, and for Fifa to call on Iran, to put an end to discrimination against women.

    Barring women from entering football stadiums is a violation of article three of the Fifa statutes, its governing document, which states: “Discrimination of any kind against any Country, private person or group of people on account of race, skin colour, ethnic, national or social origin, gender, language, religion, political opinion or any other opinion, wealth, birth or any other status, sexual orientation or any other reason is strictly prohibited and punishable by suspension or expulsion.”

    Gender-based discrimination also violates Fifa’s objectives, which are set forth in Article 2 of the statutes, include “[promoting the game of football] globally in light of its unifying, educational, cultural and humanitarian values,” as well as “[controlling] every type of Association Football by taking steps to prevent infringements of the Statutes, regulations or decisions of Fifa.” Members of Fifa are required to comply fully with the statutes pursuant to article 13. Articles 14 and 15 provide for the suspension or expulsion of any member that “seriously violates the Statutes, regulations or decisions of Fifa.”

    Iranian women – and men – have taken great risks to draw attention to gender apartheid at sporting events. Offside, a 2006 film by acclaimed director Jafar Panahi, chronicles the poignant struggle of several girls who attempt to sneak into a football match by dressing as men. In 2014, a group of women, including 25-year-old Ghoncheh Ghavami, were arrested for trying to attend a volleyball match in Tehran. Ghavami was sentenced to a year in jail, but released after several months due to an international uproar.

    In recent months, the movement has taken on a global dimension. Thousands of Iranian men and women have taken to social media and sporting events around the world, including the 2015 Asian Cup matches in Australia in January, the Iran-Sweden football friendly in Stockholm in May, and the FIVB World League volleyball matches in Los Angeles and Tehran in June, to call for an end to the ban on Iranian women in Iranian stadiums. In February, prominent Iranian activists penned a letter to Fifa president Sepp Blatter. Though Blatter expressed public support for their cause, the situation in Iran remains unchanged.

    In tackling gender discrimination, Fifa can take example from its strong position against racism. Fifa has promoted widely its Say No to Racism campaign, including at matches and across various media. Fifa’s Resolution on the Fight against Racism and Discrimination in its 63rd session of the Fifa congress, held in May 2013, established requirements for competition organizers to formulate concrete action plans to fight racism and deploy anti-discrimination officers in every match, and prescribed a stricter application of sanctions in response to violations.

    Instead of expelling the Islamic republic of Iran football federation from Fifa - which would crush the spirit of tens of millions of Iranians - similar anti-gender discrimination rules, regulations, programs and publicity campaigns could provide Fifa and the global community of football fans with more effective tools to enforce and promote Fifa policies and bring an end to discrimination against women in the world of football.

    Such strong actions are necessary if Fifa is to remain faithful to its statutes and guiding principles, including its commitment to promote football as a unifying force.

    http://www.persianfootball.com/forum...ts-and-covered
    https://www.facebook.com/Letiranianw...rtheirstadiums
    49
    Yes
    0%
    22
    No
    0%
    27


    S - E - C - U - L - A - R - I - S - M

    #2
    definitely. it is there Rights to attend games, whether they want to go or not is up to them, but they should have the right!!
    IRI = FAILED

    Comment


      #3
      No because then we would be suspended from wcq

      Comment


        #4
        If they haven't after 30+ years, they are not about to enforce a ban now.
        I went to Sharif University. I'm a superior genetic mutation, an improvement on the existing mediocre stock.

        Comment


          #5
          FIFA should do a lot of things and never does the right thing.

          Comment


            #6
            Why not Saudi Arabia?

            Comment


              #7
              No. Because then we're automatically out of World Cup 2018.

              Comment


                #8
                I am 50/50 on this issue... I know we would be tossed from 2018 WCQ but look bigger picture everyone. Women are people too and should have the rights to go to games just like us. Ofcourse I wouldnt want us to get banned and I would feel terrible for our players and CQ especially, but some punishments need to happen to get the point across. Same should happen to Saudi Arabia. Remember it also says "temporarily".... So FIFA should ban Iran and monitor the league to see if any changes are made... If not, then keep the punishment... If changes are made, then we can continue the WCQ in September.

                For example, look at the Jerry Sandusky scandel with Penn State football. The actions of one man got the entire program under probation which hurt players and coaches. However, the punishment was very much necessary in order to clean up their program. Now that the punishment is lifted this year, they have their program back in the right direction.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by naderb94 View Post
                  I am 50/50 on this issue... I know we would be tossed from 2018 WCQ but look bigger picture everyone. Women are people too and should have the rights to go to games just like us. Ofcourse I wouldnt want us to get banned and I would feel terrible for our players and CQ especially, but some punishments need to happen to get the point across. Same should happen to Saudi Arabia. Remember it also says "temporarily".... So FIFA should ban Iran and monitor the league to see if any changes are made... If not, then keep the punishment... If changes are made, then we can continue the WCQ in September.

                  For example, look at the Jerry Sandusky scandel with Penn State football. The actions of one man got the entire program under probation which hurt players and coaches. However, the punishment was very much necessary in order to clean up their program. Now that the punishment is lifted this year, they have their program back in the right direction.
                  It doesn't' work that way. If you're suspended in the middle of an ongoing tournament you're gone for that whole tournament.
                  The only time that would be ok for TM to get banned temporarily is between the end of World Cup and Asian Cup.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I think FIFA has a lot of its own problems at the moment to worry about women entering stadiums in Iran.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      are the people who actually said yes fvcking serious? BAN TM? This is the most absurd thing I ever heard. In the time when women could attend games, pre I.R.I , it was pretty rare that they did anyway. Now it has become some sort of figurehead to out I.R.I or say how wrong they are. Most of the people don't really give a fvck about football, but just want to make a political statement by saying that women MUST be allowed to enter the stadium. Thats political interference with sport too...I am not saying that women shouldn't be allowed to go to game, they should, but to ban TM for it would just be absurd and completely unneccesary.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Theres no gaurantee we will make the World Cup every 4 years. The last thing we need is to ban our team.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Do you think the regime will really care if Iran gets banned from playing football? I think football and sports are the least of their priorities.

                          And I really don't want TM to get banned, as it unjustifiably unfair to both the players and the coach who have nothing to do this with this issue. It will effect the team more than the regime. The regime doesn't care.

                          I just don't get why women have to be banned from stadiums. I know its definitely nothing to do with religion, its just the regime's bizarre and extreme propaganda.

                          When Asian Cup happened in Australia, there were as many Iranian women in the stands as Men. I didn't see any problem or issue with that. Everyone was simply happy and cheering for their country.

                          It just makes sick of why Iran has to always has to try and be different from the rest of the world.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Mir Javad View Post
                            Do you think the regime will really care if Iran gets banned from playing football? I think football and sports are the least of their priorities.

                            And I really don't want TM to get banned, as it unjustifiably unfair to both the players and the coach who have nothing to do this with this issue. It will effect the team more than the regime. The regime doesn't care.

                            I just don't get why women have to be banned from stadiums. I know its definitely nothing to do with religion, its just the regime's bizarre and extreme propaganda.

                            When Asian Cup happened in Australia, there were as many Iranian women in the stands as Men. I didn't see any problem or issue with that. Everyone was simply happy and cheering for their country.

                            It just makes sick of why Iran has to always has to try and be different from the rest of the world.
                            Au contraire


                            S - E - C - U - L - A - R - I - S - M

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Why would any of us want to ban TM at such a crucial time? Lmao

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X