Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2018 AFC U-19 Championship

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Red card for Taha. Iran down to 10 men.

    Comment


      I went through the rules again, if Syria and Jordan tie, we all have 5 points.

      Tiebreakers:
      1.Points in head-to-head matches among tied teams; => everyone has 2 points from two ties, still equal
      2.Goal difference in head-to-head matches among tied teams; => everyone has goal difference 0, still equal
      3.Goals scored in head-to-head matches among tied teams; => this could be crucial!!!

      If they tie 0-0: Syria and Iran shot one goal, Jordan 0 => Jordan out (3rd). Next tie-breaker is goal difference in all matches, Iran wins, Iran 1st!
      If they tie 1-1: Syria has 2 goals from 2 draws, Iran and Jordan have 1 goal from 2 draws. => Syria first, and the tie-breaker goes on for Iran and Jordan (making Iran 2nd, Jordan 3rd).
      If they tie 2-2 (or more): Syria 1st, Jordan 2nd, Iran 3rd

      So actually only one situation can make us qualify:
      Tie between Jordan and Syria 0-0.

      Comment


        ^so we have quite a few scenarios where we can advance.

        1- S and J tie 0-0
        2- S and J tie 1-1
        3- S Vs. J has a winner

        Not bad

        Comment


          Originally posted by Doctor DOOM View Post
          ^so we have quite a few scenarios where we can advance.
          1- S and J tie 0-0
          2- S and J tie 1-1
          3- S Vs. J has a winner
          Not bad
          You sure? If there is a winner, we finish 2nd ...

          Comment


            Originally posted by Doctor DOOM View Post
            ^so we have quite a few scenarios where we can advance.

            1- S and J tie 0-0
            2- S and J tie 1-1
            3- S Vs. J has a winner

            Not bad
            We are out in any scenario in which we become 2nd. See the page before. Out of the 10 second placed teams, we are on the 8th or 9th place (out of 10). Only the first 5 qualify.
            Only way to qualify is to become first and this is only possible by a 0-0 tie.

            Comment


              Half time in Jordan, still 0-0. If it stays like this, we are through!

              Comment


                Syria scored. Over.

                Comment


                  1-1, sorry to say, but we are out.

                  Comment


                    The tiebreakers are kind of stupid though. When they play 2-2 or higher, Syria is first, Jordan second and Iran third, even though all of them have 5 points BUT Irans overall goal difference is 4, Jordans is 2 and Syrias is 1. So exactly the other way round.

                    Comment


                      I don't get it, why is 90 saying that Iran has already advanced regardless of what happens in the other game??

                      http://90tv.ir/news/425154/%D9%85%D9...AF%D9%86%D8%AF

                      Comment


                        makes no sense Iran has the highest goal difference. Why would they be out?
                        "History is a set of lies that people have agreed upon,"

                        Comment


                          Jordan just scored - 2-1 in the 74th min.

                          Comment


                            I explained it on the page before. We have 3 teams with 5 points (if Jordan/Syria tied).

                            One last time:
                            By tiebreakers we become first, if they play 0-0. We become second if they play 1-1 or any of the teams win. We become third if they play 2-2 or any higher ties, because the important tiebreaker is:
                            "3. Goals scored in head-to-head matches among tied teams;"
                            0-0 tie -> Iran 1 goal, Syria 1 goal, Jordan 0 goals => next tiebreaker between Syria-Iran which is then overall goal difference => Iran advances
                            1-1 tie -> Iran 1, Syria 2, Jordan 1 => Syria is first anyway, Iran and Jordan go to next tiebreaker which is overall goal difference => Iran second, Jordan 3rd
                            2-2 tie (or higher) -> Iran 1, Syria 3, Jordan 2 => Syria first, Jordan second, Iran 3rd.

                            And the second-placed team is definitely out. Just look at the table at Wikipedia:
                            https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_A..._qualification

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by versusdamon View Post
                              I explained it on the page before. We have 3 teams with 5 points (if Jordan/Syria tied).

                              One last time:
                              By tiebreakers we become first, if they play 0-0. We become second if they play 1-1 or any of the teams win. We become third if they play 2-2 or any higher ties, because the important tiebreaker is:
                              "3. Goals scored in head-to-head matches among tied teams;"
                              0-0 tie -> Iran 1 goal, Syria 1 goal, Jordan 0 goals => next tiebreaker between Syria-Iran which is then overall goal difference => Iran advances
                              1-1 tie -> Iran 1, Syria 2, Jordan 1 => Syria is first anyway, Iran and Jordan go to next tiebreaker which is overall goal difference => Iran second, Jordan 3rd
                              2-2 tie (or higher) -> Iran 1, Syria 3, Jordan 2 => Syria first, Jordan second, Iran 3rd.

                              And the second-placed team is definitely out. Just look at the table at Wikipedia:
                              https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_A..._qualification
                              Seems like AFC has its own dumb rules again. Usually its points first then goal difference then head to head results
                              "History is a set of lies that people have agreed upon,"

                              Comment


                                I think Iran Advance

                                http://www.flashscore.com/soccer/asi...u19/standings/

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X