Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Serbia Nigeria Morocco Panama , which team do we want from pot 4

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #61
    Panama, because we already beat them!

    Comment


      #62
      Originally posted by rjafari View Post
      I forgot about Mexico in pot 2 good point, so actually based on those conditions for Serbia and Panama, the odds of getting either Morocco or Nigeria then conditionally become slightly higher - but i'm too lazy to do the math in expectation.
      once the 3 pots are drawn we'll know the direct probability
      but in expectation
      morocco/nigeria are most likely - ends up slightly higher than 50% currently
      panama after that
      serbia after that
      ---
      If we get 1 European team and 1 South American team
      all will be likely at 25%
      if we get Mexico - panama drops and we get 33% each on the remaining 3
      similarly if we get 2 European teams, Serbia drops and we get 33% each on the remaining 3
      ---
      EDIT: Ok I stopped being bored and did a quick back of the envelope calculation (someone please correct me if i'm wrong here)
      Nigeria 28.57%
      Morocco 28.57%
      Panama 25%
      Serbia 17.86%
      EDIT:
      last World Cup draw they first draw group headers than pot 2 team, but than the position for which group, which position.....than 3 and so on.., than 4....
      If we get mexico from pot 2 (12,5% chance, we won´t face Panama anymore.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqR9DiGII3U
      World Cup 2006, Frankfurt, Iran vs. Portugal, Iranian Frontpage of GOAL Sportspaper
      sigpic

      And on the 8.Day God created Ali Karimi, and he saw he was good!
      If Defenders were allowed to use their hands to stop Karimi
      -

      Comment


        #63
        Originally posted by saeed_noro View Post
        50% we get an African team (Morocco / Nigeria) and 25% we get Serbia (and another European team of pot 2 or 1) and 25% we get Panama, but avoid mexico and get 2 European teams, or one European and South American team.
        whatever happens. we must be in form. and fight for advancing.
        Mersi Agha Saeed for all your pot expertise input.

        Of all those teams, I'd avoid Nigeria. Physically, it will be extremely hard to impose ourselves on them. We have the ability to handle Serbia, Morocco or Panama.

        Overall we seem to match up better with Latin Americans (perhaps except Brazil) compared to Europeans, but you never know what CQ can take out of his magic box this time.

        Comment


          #64
          Originally posted by saeed_noro View Post
          I am very sure they will start with pot 4, than 3, than 2, than 1...so avoiding mexiko is very high (25% = the chance of getting Panama out of 4 teams we could get draw too.
          i will watch youtube last World Cup how they did it..
          Oh that's a good point too - I was basing this on 1 to 4, it is also super conditional on a ) how they do the pots and b ) if they draw a team does it go in First available group from A->H? I legit don't remember that and went on those assumptions.

          I thought they did it Pot 1 -> 4
          and then A-> H
          so for any team (say in pot 3) that is drawn (say for group C) if it can't go in Group C it goes in D and the next team then goes potentially to C (or E) and so on.

          Comment


            #65
            I hope they will make the draw like last time. otherwise position 3 in the group have bad venues in total. just b3 position is good.
            first group headers....
            Then pot 4 team, than position AND group of this team...
            then pot 3 team, than position AND group of this team....
            then pot 2 team...and last position in a random group..
            World Cup 2006, Frankfurt, Iran vs. Portugal, Iranian Frontpage of GOAL Sportspaper
            sigpic

            And on the 8.Day God created Ali Karimi, and he saw he was good!
            If Defenders were allowed to use their hands to stop Karimi
            -

            Comment


              #66
              World Cup 2006, Frankfurt, Iran vs. Portugal, Iranian Frontpage of GOAL Sportspaper
              sigpic

              And on the 8.Day God created Ali Karimi, and he saw he was good!
              If Defenders were allowed to use their hands to stop Karimi
              -

              Comment


                #67
                Originally posted by saeed_noro View Post
                I hope they will make the draw like last time. otherwise position 3 in the group have bad venues in total. just b3 position is good.
                first group headers....
                Then pot 2 team, than position AND group of this team...
                then pot 3 team, than position AND group of this team....
                Agreed. Ok so I went back and for a sanity check cleared it all for myself. (and found this video on 2010 that I'm basing this on).
                Based on 2010 Draw: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amMAqNklRqw
                Assumption 1: You fill Pot 1 teams first , then 2, then 3, then 4
                Assumption 2: You then fill in order A->H in the first available group
                Assumption 3: You randomly assign position Within the group - with Pot 1 teams taking position 1, and pot 2-4 randomly filling in the rest
                In this scenario, there are 58 possible groupings after pots 1 and 2 are drawn (because south american teams cannot be in the same pot, so reducing that from a total of 64).
                Of these 58, Iran can end up in any of them.
                Of these 58 - Nigeria can also go in any of them
                Of these 58 - Morocco can also go in any of them
                Of these 58 - Panama can only go in 50 of them (8 combinations eliminated due to Mexico)
                Of these 58 - Serbia can only go in 34 of them (eliminated due to 2 European teams)
                Resulting in:
                Morocco: 29% likelihood
                Nigeria: 29% likelihood
                Panama: 25% likelihood
                Serbia: 17% likelihood

                EDIT: Actually - that might not be right because the scenarios where Iran is not in a group with 2 European teams might not be as evenly distributed because of other European teams in Pot 3

                Comment


                  #68
                  Originally posted by saeed_noro View Post
                  I hope the social media idiots don't embarrass us again.

                  Comment


                    #69
                    Interestingly our first group match will be against seed 4 team. That will probably determine our chance of progression into the second round.

                    Comment


                      #70
                      wait so what percent chance do we have for each pot four opponent. ??

                      Comment


                        #71
                        1. Panama: We know how they play and this is their first WC. Nerves will be in play for them.
                        2. Morocco: Probably the weakest African team in WC, very inexperienced players on international level, lack of WC experience.
                        3. Nigeria: We know how they play, but they have new talented players like Iwobi and Inechnacho who could give us trouble.
                        4. Serbia: Always a gritty, tough European team. Similar to Bosnia from 2014

                        Comment


                          #72
                          Originally posted by naderb94 View Post
                          1. Panama: We know how they play and this is their first WC. Nerves will be in play for them.
                          2. Morocco: Probably the weakest African team in WC, very inexperienced players on international level, lack of WC experience.
                          3. Nigeria: We know how they play, but they have new talented players like Iwobi and Inechnacho who could give us trouble.
                          4. Serbia: Always a gritty, tough European team. Similar to Bosnia from 2014
                          I would have to say on paper Tunisia are far weaker than morocco. Morocco actually have very talented players like Boufal ( Southampton), Hakimi ( Real Madrid), Hakim Ziyech ( Ajax), Belhanda ( ex schalke,nice, now galatasaray), Benatia( Juventus), Amrabat( on watford last year), Amrabat( feyenoord), Amine Harit ( Schalke), Dirar ( ex monaco now fener), Saiss ( Wolverhampton). A match with morocco would be very, very difficult. They have real quality players that could hurt us if they play as a team. I can see them becoming the African success story, in the mold of algeria in last WC.

                          Tunisia on the other hand have basically one legionairre in wahbi Khazri, and do not have as much talent(on paper) besides him. Not sure how they are in pot three.

                          Comment


                            #73
                            Originally posted by inarsenewetrust View Post
                            I would have to say on paper Tunisia are far weaker than morocco. Morocco actually have very talented players like Boufal ( Southampton), Hakimi ( Real Madrid), Hakim Ziyech ( Ajax), Belhanda ( ex schalke,nice, now galatasaray), Benatia( Juventus), Amrabat( on watford last year), Amrabat( feyenoord), Amine Harit ( Schalke), Dirar ( ex monaco now fener), Saiss ( Wolverhampton). A match with morocco would be very, very difficult. They have real quality players that could hurt us if they play as a team. I can see them becoming the African success story, in the mold of algeria in last WC.

                            Tunisia on the other hand have basically one legionairre in wahbi Khazri, and do not have as much talent(on paper) besides him. Not sure how they are in pot three.
                            Exactly.
                            I bet if he had players at those clubs many of our fans would have expected TM to go to quarters at least.
                            On paper we are the underdogs in this world cup, perhaps with exception of Panama.
                            Having said that, we have a potential to create problems for any team on a good day.

                            Comment


                              #74
                              Originally posted by GolfePersique View Post
                              Exactly.
                              I bet if he had players at those clubs many of our fans would have expected TM to go to quarters at least.
                              On paper we are the underdogs in this world cup, perhaps with exception of Panama.
                              Having said that, we have a potential to create problems for any team on a good day.
                              well no question we are better than the likes of Panama, other Asian teams except Japan. We are probably at the level of morocco,Costa Rica if we are being honest, and im fine with that for now

                              Comment


                                #75
                                to conclude, tunisia is less strong compared to morroco. this is right.

                                morocco did something, which we did not do. they finished their Group without conceding a Goal. specially a super Performance in the last game, where ivory coast needed a victory to qualify. but they had nothing to say. morocco has a good defense, and structure, same as our Team melli. but they finished without conceding. fifty fifty game, still i prefer them after morocco.
                                World Cup 2006, Frankfurt, Iran vs. Portugal, Iranian Frontpage of GOAL Sportspaper
                                sigpic

                                And on the 8.Day God created Ali Karimi, and he saw he was good!
                                If Defenders were allowed to use their hands to stop Karimi
                                -

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X