Carlos Queiroz In or Carlos Queiroz Out?

[tooleh khers]

The way you swing those percentage are so unscientific!

If you want to achieve a somewhat comparable percentage you have to calculate the ratio of the opponents average ranking in proportion to yours. Simply if one coach plays 4 games against Brazil, Argentina, France and Germany, and the other plays against the Maldives and the co - then comparing the win % between the two coaches is useless. Unfortunately FIFA ranking can't be used either as team rankings fluctuate seasonally depending on their tournament participation (for example, the Syria team that made the WC qualification playoff in 2018 was a better team but had an average ranking of 132, and the Syria that ended in the bottom of the table in 2022 was ranked 88)


As for your assessment that a 60% ratio and 0 Asian cups achievement is not hard to beat, then why haven't we won the cup in 46 years? Why no other coaches managed to get 4 points at the world cup? Why is that prior to CQ only 3 coaches qualifies us to the world cup? Seriously though, if you don't look like CQ's demeanor, character or coaching style you can simply say that, but distorting facts it only makes you look silly.

Exactly! and this was discussed with the Branko vs CQ comparison. It was pointed out to the anger of the unscientific crowd that the average ranking of CQ opponents are quite a bit lower as well. On your second argument in bold, yes precisely that is why other coaches who did not win the Asian cup did beat his achievements. It is easy to beat 0 cups and 60% win percentage. It is rofoozeh grade. It is unscientific to want to make it into an A.

[milad_b]

Saudi arabia is after CQ. Renard is perfect replacement for skocic

[armen]

Saudi arabia is after CQ. Renard is perfect replacement for skocic

The Saudis just gave Renard a 5 year contract extension:
https://www.arabnews.com/node/2092101/sport
Why would they now be after CQ?

[ParthianDE]

So it said Asian team and its not Iran, Australia or Saudi. It can't possibly be S. Korea.

So that leaves Qatar or Japan?

[ParthianDE]

Did it say world cup asian team though?

If not it could be Uzbekistan etc, lol!

[Nokhodi]

The Saudis just gave Renard a 5 year contract extension:
https://www.arabnews.com/node/2092101/sport
Why would they now be after CQ?

They're alarmists and very trigger happy.
I would be surprised as well as they seem to actually be behind Renard now, but their results in their friendlies really upset them.

[Gol Bezan]

Then who? Please tell us!

Sent from my SM-G973W using Tapatalk

Been asked not to say just now

[tooleh khers]

Saudi arabia is after CQ. Renard is perfect replacement for skocic

That would be a great signing for Saudi. They will go to the second round with him.

[milad_b]

The Saudis just gave Renard a 5 year contract extension:
https://www.arabnews.com/node/2092101/sport
Why would they now be after CQ?

Yes I know this but its saudi arabia! They fire coaches within days of signing. They renewed his contract untill 2027 but the fans are not happy with him. He is in exactly the same situation as skocic is right now.

[milad_b]

They're alarmists and very trigger happy.
I would be surprised as well as they seem to actually be behind Renard now, but their results in their friendlies really upset them.

Not just the friendly results. Their performance against weak asian teams have been alarming for them.

[milad_b]

Been asked not to say just now

Its saudi arabia

Lol very stupid of saudi arabia to let renard go but we'll take him lol

[O-ZoNe]

That would be a great signing for Saudi. They will go to the second round with him.

Even God cannot get them to the second round lol

Sent from my SM-G973W using Tapatalk

[Nokhodi]

Even God cannot get them to the second round lol

Sent from my SM-G973W using Tapatalk

God is with them. They get awarded a penalty or two every world cup (not to mention the qualifiers), plus in 1994 every single thing that could go right for them did and they qualified to the 2nd round! Go look at Saeed Owairon's goal - it's like the Belgians were all struck down by disease.

[Gol Bezan]

Its saudi arabia

Lol very stupid of saudi arabia to let renard go but we'll take him lol

Nope.

[scuderia]

Nope.

I really hope I'm right but if it wasn't Iran, I don't think you would be posting . Fingers crossed that it's Iran.