How do you rate this transfer window?
-
32Excellent0%3Good0%18Average0%7Bad0%4Awful0%0 -
Best transfer : Taremi finally leaving the middle east.
Best transfer day : The day Taremi signed with Rio Ave. The same day Beiro was on Tuttosport front page
++ : Taremi to Rio Ave
++ : Mehrdad Mohammadi to Aves
+ : Allayar to Fenerbahçe
+ : Milad to Gent
+ : Ebrahimi and Ezatolahi to Eupen
+ : Ghoddos non-transfert to Brentford
+/- : Rezaei to Charleroi
+/- JB refusal to leave Brighton/Join PSV
- : Allahyar to istanbulspor
- Salimi non-transfer to Greece
-- : Ansarifard to Qatar
-- : PP jail : Beiro& Alipour
? : Cheshmi to... -
agree with all those, except ARJ failure to leave brighton is surely a - for me.Originally posted by PSGman#19 View PostComment
-
Now people realise the role of CQ for our league and players. CQ leaves the league becomes a disaster.
Compared to last year pretty bad if you ask me.
Good transfers: Mehrdad Mohammadi to Aves - Milad mohammadi to Gent
Bad ones:
Ghoddos ban really shocked me. I really loved to see this guy playing against hong kong.
Alahyar transfer is awful ! Beiro staying in PP is also stupid . Unless all the news about big teams wanting is rumors. Cheshmi situation is also bad at the moment.Comment
-
Average Transfer window
The good:
-Average players getting a chance in Europe.
-A lot of tranfers
The bad:
- Beiro
- Kaveh pushed out of Brugge
- Ghoddos stuck in a shit hole and suspended
- Milmo's transfer was underwhelming considering his quality.
- No transfers to EPL
-
Comment
-
Honestly Beiranvand not moving was worse than any mediocre move. He's stagnated in Iran but could've reached his full potential in Italy.Comment
-
The guy is trolling everyone with his 4years contract extension with PP. I don't even want to hear about him hahaOriginally posted by Dortmund View PostComment
-
I rated it as excellent. Not only has it been a good transfer windows for Iranian football, but football in general/as a whole! This has honestly been one of the best transfers (if not the best in quite awhile, so many transfers in football!)Originally posted by PSGman#19
With that being said, I really look forward to the Winter transfer window and especially considering the way Portuguese fans have been talking about our football I look forward to more of them going to LigaNOS. Maybe CD Aves/Rio Ave invests in more of our players considering they’ve gotten their money’s worth so far.Comment
-
Not to forget his recent behavior at Persepolis has been disastrous BeirangandComment
-
This pretty much sums it up.. Beiranvand is such a shame..Originally posted by PSGman#19 View Post
However, how is Ghoddos non-transfer a plus? I understand Brentford is a second tier team compared to Aimens, but wasnt there another 1st tier team that wanted him?#WilmotsOUTComment
-
-
Had beiranvand and cheshmi made moves I would have voted excellent. Salimi being stuck in Iran was sad to see too but aside from those 3 guys there were lots of great moves all around that I think TM will benefit from a lot this upcoming yearTeam Meli Iran
Perspolis FC
Malavan Bandar Anzali
"I will never be able to say good bye to Iran. I have a feeling of belonging to this country and to the people." - Carlos QueirozComment
-
Hitting police ... swearing at the fans .... and now doing the elbow gesture (f*ck off) to tractor fans. Oh also hitting players and doing swearing gestures in sepahan game i think. He already has a case and now traktor have official filed a lawsuit against him.Originally posted by ramingeles2000 View Post
Used to love his fighting personality now i just like him as player. Totally disapointed me.Comment
-
give the guy a break he went from washing SUVs to saving Ronaldo PKs in like 4 years. Talented TM players fall into two camps:Originally posted by milad_b View Post
1) The Mature, Career-Oriented Camp: These are the Hashemian, AJB, Mahdavikia, Daei, Ansarifard, Hajisafi, Nekounam, Shojaei (and now, refreshingly) Taremis of the world....guys who are tough and willing and able and have the maturity to forgo fame and easy money in Iran/Qatar, deal with discomfort, learn a foreign culture, try to take their game to the next level. Though he didn't quite take the step abroad, I'd put Sattar Zare in this group as well.
2) The Emotional, Fame-Seeking, Hashiyeh-Magnet, Iran4Life Camp: These are players who are arguably just as talented as the first camp, but lack the social/mental wherewithal, maturity, toughness and (likely) guidance to take their careers to the next step (which usually means going to Europe). Think Mehdi Rahmati, Payam Sadeghian, Ali Karimi, Farhad Majidi, etc. Beiranvand likely falls into this group. I'm willing to bet he'll never leave the Middle East.
Sometimes, players can turn it around and leapfrog from camp 2 to camp 1 - like Taremi. Some players try to join camp 1, but their true nature puts them back in camp 2 - this describes Ali Karimi. Sardar also showed signs that he might fall into this trap but has done well to stay above it and mature.
It's not just talent on the field that progresses a footballing career. It's also toughness, maturity and willingness to leave your comfort zone. Many talented iranian players lack this mentality unfortunately. At WC2018 I had the chance to talk to a coach in the Japan Football Federation for almost 2 hours. He said that Japanese players had major issues adapting to foreign leagues (language, culture, immaturity). The JFA started paying for psychologists, cultural adjustment training and for the players parents to move with them to the new country.Comment
-
Excellent transfers:
Allahyar to Fener
Taremi to Rio Ave
Mehrdad Mo to Aves
Good transfers: Milad to Gent
Ebrahimi and Ezatollahi to Eupen.
Rezaei back to Charleroi
Bad: Beiranvand staying in iran to throw rocks in lorestan
Ansarifard going to Qatar
JB stuck in brighton wasting his career.AKP Parti, Turkiye - Haj Bernie SandersogluComment
Comment