[POLL] How do you rate this summer transfer window 2022 ?

[PSGman#19]

How do you rate this summer transfer window for our players?

[PSGman#19]

General appreciation : Bad.

Wasn't expecting an impressive transfer window as the main transfer occured before (Azmoun to Leverkusen, Taremi to Porto) and most of legionnaires had/have quite a bad season in Europe. It seems last year we reached a peak for our euro transfers and now come the reflux. If we don't have a good WC, I think we will get less and less euro legionnaires and maybe reach the 2008/2012 dark period.

Details :

++ : Hosseinzadeh to Charleroi.
= : Alipour to Gil Vincente, Ansarifard to Omonia
the rest is between average (=) and bad (-) :
No big transfer for Taremi, players like JB, Ghoddos not trying/not having decent offers, Gholizadeh still at Charleroi, Abdi failed transfer to Chaves, Ezza without a club. At least, they don't rush to come back to middle east.
-- : All euro legionnaires (except Rezaei) coming back to Iran, specially Mohebi. For Beiro, his euro failure was heartbreaking but at least a PP come-back isn't that bad.

[Abtin]

who voted 'Excellent'? 😂

[BacheLot]

who voted 'Excellent'? 😂

dude musta been in the know ... that Mehdi to Chelsea is a done deal..?

[arvin_guzoo]

In context of Iranian football, it could always be much worse .

Just remind yourself of the 2007-2011.

[Medzdidz]

Going to poll my vote after Ezza goes to Liverpool.

[inarsenewetrust]

Considering how many moves we had last summer this one was always going to be a bit quieter. Our talent pool is not endless...

Sardar and allahyar were two really big transfers that happened in January. Both i would rate as good transfers, even if sardar has not found top form yet. Hosseinzadeh move was very good. Alipour + Ansarifard moves solid. Beiro and PAG to PP are both positive transfers for TM. Karimi re-emergence is like a new signing.

For a lot of players this summer was about consolidating and continuing to build. Examples:

- Majid who moved last summer, now developing into one of the most consistent performers in the league, makes no sense to move just yet.
- Moharrami is in a good place and needs to keep establishing himself (now will have a big chance to do that if he can manage CL games).
- Hajsafi - more consolidation, in a good spot.
- Abedzadeh to an extent I put into this category, although for him maybe we had hoped an early move to La Liga would materialise. Still getting #1 gig is hard as a gk, big risk to take going somewhere as a #2 in build up to WC.

Ghoddos as discussed in his thread, is in a really good PL club on good wage getting rotation mins, probably makes more sense for him to leave after WC. Currently not sure how much interest he has from what we consider "good" moves. Again, similar case with ARJ in feyenoord. I wouldn't consider him transferring to a team like utrecht a good move after what we have seen from him in recent weeks. These 2 not moving I would not consider "bad" necessarily.

Bad moves/non-moves. BC of these I still rate this window as Bad overall:

Ezatolahi no club + no preseason.
Gholi staying at charleroi. Long overdue a move and looks like he lacks motivation/has gone stale there. This and Ezatolahi are worst situations of the window by far.
Zahedi staying in hungary (even if it is a loan which upon expiry will make him free agent) - he can do a lot better.
Mohebbi return to SS. Already looks like the retarded decision we all expected, he was looking like sure starter in Santa Clara.
Niazmand return to Sepahan. Today it seems likely Samuel (first choice at Portimonense) will indeed move to Porto. Niazmand would likely have taken the #1 spot if preseason is anything to go by. Terrible choice by him.
Abdi staying in Iran. He is talented but needs euro move to develop. PP dont even plan on playing him, cant believe Yahya blocked his transfer (for decent money) to Chaves.
Delfi return to Iran is best he can do atm but still sad conclusion to what was a promising wing option for us when he first moved to charleroi at 19.


Future transfers to watch in Jan + Summer:

#1 - Yasin to EU (likely Portugal). Him staying in Sepahan for 1 yr extension is not bad given Morais arrival.
#2 - Gholi eventual move from Charleroi
#3 - Majid upgrade (top turkish side or top 5 league side)
#4 - Abdi to EU