REQUEST TO IRANIAN TV-BROADCASTERS / TV-SHOWS - IF YOU SE THIS PLZ READ

[Keshwardoost]

REQUEST TO IRANIAN TV-BROADCASTERS / TV-SHOWS - IF YOU SE THIS PLZ READ

This is maybe daydreaming by me to hope someone actually reads this and apply my suggestion - it would be great as us TM/PGPL fans deserves this.


Constructive critics that would benefint the TV-shows and the fans

#As long as I can remember I have wished for a tactical analyse and proffessional show with deep dives in analysing. To my knowladge, until today, I have not witnessed such in Iranian TV. At best case we have very elementary and basic analyses. Mostly we have arguments and guest showing documents to prove they are innocent and a lot of fighting/hashieh and boring (in my oppinon, surely some enjoy the shows) long shows with for an example 30 minutes referee misstakes analyses..

One of few things I enjoy with Brittish footballshows are their analyses, when they arnt bursting with ego they are actually inspiring.

An example is this latest episode about Englands group B tactics. I realy loved it (talks very shortly about game vs TM aswell)
The way they analyse Southgate, Phil Foden situation, 5 back defence etc, its fantastic and eyeopening.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQIJEL6f4K4


MY SUGGESTION
I would love to se something like this, atleast a segment at for an example Football Bartar show,, with actual proffessional analysers. (people with coachingdegrees or deep knowlagde. This is what I was hoping for to se in Yazdah Show, Adel Ferdousipour and Football Bartar show but its not happened yet. Please watch this 12 minute episode as inspiration as it giv es more in 12 minutes compared to most 1 hour shows.
The closes we come to this in Iranian shows are the great GOL BEZAN PODCAST and TEAM MELLI TALK SHOW on youtube, but id like to se this at TV aswell.

Also for interviews, please use the opportunity to talk about this tactical stuff, unbiased and objective without the reporter implicating his/her views in the questions. This, I missed in interviews with Skocic, CQ etc at Bartar show, Yazdah show and Adels 360 show.

If the brittish can deliver this "intelectual" discussions, the very intelectual footballcrazy Iranian people and society should be able to produce atleast the same level of intelectual discussions about tactics/players/coach etc. The people and fans dont deserve to watch dirtthrowing "Jerry Springer" shows we have to witness just to get some info about our beloved TM and preferred PGPL teams.

The fans deservere this, TM and PGPL teams and the players deserve this. It would benefit everybody as I believe the interest for a show like this would be huge. So it would aswell definaltely benefit the broadcast production company aswell - if im correct.

Its time that we as a nation show a more proffessional, respectable, and hashieh-free profile of ourselves in our broadcasts. We surely can do better than todays shows.

End of request

Keshwardoost


(Dear great PFDC mods, please excuse that I started a thread for this as we have threads about the shows, so if its spammish please close it)
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ ___________________

#Personal note, not in request

I would definately start a show if I had the correct knowladge about tactics, and so would many members here aswell. I can only speculate in tactics but I dont have any coaching degree or proper experiance except watching and playing a whole lot of football and other sports aswell.

But I know that on the forum we have some great members who actually have this confirmed knowladge. (meaning if I have a tactical analyse they could properly analyse and critisize it with tactical facts they experianced.

It would be great to have a few members, for example a segment at Team Melli Radio show or the other podcasts with PFDC members asking tactical questions to the "experts" for a 10-20 minute segment on the show a few times a month, or r a suggestion iv been thinking about for years a PFDC dedicated panel +/ "random site member invite" for a broadcast/analyse show that is displayed on PFDC frontpage 2-3 times a month.

Another PFDC suggestion

I would love to se a article with a few firm writers and some PFDC guest writers " like for an example, "Katebs Corner with todays guest Keshwardoost" - Doctor Dooms corner, Taz weekend analyse show etc, where members can produce their oppinons. (first send in and approved to post by forum staff to avoid articles that breaks site rules for insulting etc.

This would open the doors for members that feels that sites sometimes hashiehi atmosphere limits them from expressing their oppinions or write deeper analyses. We have members here with great knowladge

It would realy lift the site in my oppinion and I would gladly assist and contribute with articles.
For an example I post this fantastic thread from Mansour posted earlier this year. In this thread one can witness the great knowladge on this site that in my oppinion is sometimes hindered or faded in threads with ongoing arguments repeating themselves.

I think internet is like other "rooms" and inviroments in life, creating its own culture in possitive and negative ways. So people go in tho character and manytimes hide some of their sides as they dont know/think it fits and is accepted/appreciated in that enviroment. Personally for an example, I joke a lot on PFDC and dont write to much longer tactical analyses, just on reflex. But if we open few doors the site can fourish even more, to an other level as member experiance.


Maybe my suggestion can lift this hidden PFDC knowladge to the surface, or spark another member to have an idea about this subject.


Thanks for reading this long post. It got a bit longer than I was planning


Cheers, much love, free Iranian people and great weekend to you all.

[perspolis#1]

I like your suggestions for the site and I would also volunteer to help write some articles if needed. Of course, emphasis should be on objective analysis and not too much of our opinions(even if we think ourselves pundits).

As for your suggestion regarding Iranian TV newsbroadcasters, without risking sounding snooty a lot of people in the media world of IR got there because of who their amoo or their naneh is in the organization not how related they are to football, not sure they would be amenable to being replaced by actually competent people.

[Keshwardoost]

I like your suggestions for the site and I would also volunteer to help write some articles if needed. Of course, emphasis should be on objective analysis and not too much of our opinions(even if we think ourselves pundits).
As for your suggestion regarding Iranian TV newsbroadcasters, without risking sounding snooty a lot of people in the media world of IR got there because of who their amoo or their naneh is in the organization not how related they are to football, not sure they would be amenable to being replaced by actually competent people.

Thanks my friend, im glad to read your post.
About the second part of your post, I agree, didnt think about it when I wrote it but its correct. My hope is that someone, maybe a up and coming producer or one of the ones who got there through contacts reads this, gets a new thought and angle, sees the opportunity to produce a show that is loved and becomes an houshold name amongs Iranians and seizes this oppertunity. There is a void, a vacuum atm as this is missing in the portfolio offered to the fans.
I mean the changes I suggest isnt an economic issue or costly, so it doesnt cost a thing to try them, and thats a great sidenote and enabler itself. they would probably/possibly make more money out of it aswell concidering more viewers?
ATM one must "endure" 70 % of the show just to get to the part with highlights or interviews.
Even those who got their jobs through connections, unfit for their position compared to some, could benefit from this as in the end its about viewers for them. I mean try it out for a season, make a pilot episode and se how it goes. We can allwayz go back to the concept that we have today.
Thats what made me dissapointed in the Yazdah show, they have the knowladge (hopefully), should just had 1-2 coaches aswell there and took the show to another level.
Same with Adels show. In his defence he maybe miss that knowladge I have no idea, but his shows are slightly better than bartar show since he takes it a bit more intelectuall, but its still at a low level if you are a tactical nerd like me. Its to elementary, to many implications make headline reactions from the guests etc.
id rate todays shows
A+ no one atm even though Gol Bezan is getting closer and closer as they get warm in their cothes over the years.

Gol Bezan Pending between pending between A- to B+ ( great football knowladge, nice discussions proffessional would love to se even more tactical talks like the one I
posted in first post in this thread

Team Melli Talk Show - pending A- to B - to get to an A, (would like to se longer shows as he does have gread knowladge and analyses, but under 10 minutes is to short to dig deap instead of scratch the surface
Adel: c+

yazdah show: c- to d entertaining but still dissapointing

bartar show: c- to e -
could do a lot of improvements as they have all the tools for success such as TV time, economic muscle, access to high profile guest etc, cut out the
legal stuff arguments between the guests, no one is interested, just post them online instead or shorten it down, the segment with referee mistakes is waaaaaaaaay to long and makes one doze of. has good segments and the interviewer asks bold questions at times that i have liked. could improve a lot without changing the layup, just cut some things in lenght, add some features, and make it more proffessional.

for me this is A+ in tactica talks, and they behaviour could be copy pasted to some other segments aswell
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQIJEL6f4K4

[Keshwardoost]

I like your suggestions for the site and I would also volunteer to help write some articles if needed. Of course, emphasis should be on objective analysis and not too much of our opinions(even if we think ourselves pundits).
As for your suggestion regarding Iranian TV newsbroadcasters, without risking sounding snooty a lot of people in the media world of IR got there because of who their amoo or their naneh is in the organization not how related they are to football, not sure they would be amenable to being replaced by actually competent people.

I for one would love to read one of your articles (not post but a actuall article), and same goes for many members. Even those I not often agree with as I enjoy reading their post and their oppinions challange my views and makes new thoughts pop up. We do have some great members here, all from the way some write, to the way some think.
I believe the key for best way to progress sometimes is within the squad. dont need to spend allwayz or look for new folks, just twist some screws, tighten or loosen up some stuff, use new angles and most important, use the knowladge hidden within the squad. And try to challange the way you think and do stuff.

The biggest shame is the waste of earned eperiance and hidden knowladge vapouriseng away instead of leading to good things, To bring that to surface new rooms/mental or physical and enviroments needs to be created where the flow is welcomed and promoted. Most importantly, make the squad, from the newest most inexperianced to the oldest most experianced feew envolved in the future. Top steering is important and needs to be done at times but can also lead to stagnation, it has to be mixed with everybody being able to contribute or feel envolved or atleast up to date with where are we, whats our aim and where are we going - and how. this can even be applied to mediabroadcasts or even PFDC to open future doors that wont be opened or known of if envolvement isnt there. Like a family, parents decide but kids should be envolved aswell and might surprise the parents with new thoughts that benefit all at moments. Hope we use our great members knowladge in the future and that it leads us to another 25 years of PFDC flourishing in to the future.

I also thought about following alternative version: creating an clear cut ARTICLE THREAD, so members just can write whatever they want as an article, post it there, and a thread for discussions and then maybe even the staff can pick an article to post on a weekly/monthly basis. Its not the same as tactical analyse i posted about in post 1 but would still be cool.

But I dont know if there is enough interest for such a thing. Iv posted threads before that just faded away after 2 posts but
ok im going to stop posting now to many ideas popping up in my mind taking focus away from post 1 about tactics. lol