Best Left Back?

[milad]

With all due respect, this is one of silly poll.

Maldini is a legend, Carlos is just a good defender. That's the difference. Ask the people who know soccer, not a bunch of 16 year old Brazilian fans (uhum uhum, Milad kind!)

whats with the cheap shot?

you are not logical man... your unusual love for italy is blinding any sense of logic that you have. you say "maldini is a legend, carlos is just a good defender", hows that even logical? then you attack me by saying im 16 which is supposed to mean IM not logical.

[ShirFarhad]

Maldini was a much better defender but I have always been a fan of Roberto Carlos so no player will get a vote over him

[Amin_]

This is a tough one, but I gotta go with Maldini.

[VivaItalia]

whats with the cheap shot?

you are not logical man... your unusual love for italy is blinding any sense of logic that you have. you say "maldini is a legend, carlos is just a good defender", hows that even logical? then you attack me by saying im 16 which is supposed to mean IM not logical.

When Maldini was selected the best LB for several years, your parrent's weren't even sure if they wanna have a kid named Milad or not.

That's why I say, don't ask 16 year old kids. You guys don't even remember how Maldini played.

and for your information, Maldini was selected in many many century selections by magazines. I'm not saying that Carlos is inferior to Maldini, No, but Maldini is a legend. Carlos is not. Legends usually wear Captain's armband for a long time, Carlos never did! Maldini is a natural leader, Carlos never was!

You see the difference now?

[VivaItalia]

here is a memory of WC90.


watch the last 30 seconds. can you find a worse judgement than this?!?

[VivaItalia]

here is the champion's compilation, enjoy...

[milad]

here is a memory of WC90.


watch the last 30 seconds. can you find a worse judgement than this?!?

whats this got to do with the greatest leftback of all time vote?

[PersianMadrid7]

For someone that says R.Carlos is not a legend, I don't think it's necessary to continue arguing with him.

[persiangodfather]

wow i didnt see this poll before so i cudnt vote but this just shows how most of u guys hate on italians

paolo maldini has been the best defender of all time no defender in the past has been better then him

wow i cant believe how much some of u hate on italians

[milad]

wow i didnt see this poll before so i cudnt vote but this just shows how most of u guys hate on italians
paolo maldini has been the best defender of all time no defender in the past has been better then him
wow i cant believe how much some of u hate on italians

why do italy fans always make these kind of excuses. PFDC thinks roberto carlos is a better left back. end of story.

[persiangodfather]

first of all maldini can play left back right back center back he is a defender NOT an attacker rc can onl play left back. Maldinis game is not about attacking its about defending so this poll is like comparin karimi with nekounam.

and for defending no other defender can even come close to maldini

but for an attaacking defender rc is one of the best

[BacheLot]

first of all maldini can play left back right back center back he is a defender NOT an attacker rc can onl play left back. Maldinis game is not about attacking its about defending so this poll is like comparin karimi with nekounam.
and for defending no other defender can even come close to maldini
but for an attaacking defender rc is one of the best

i agree here somewhat...!
we are not comparing apples to apples here...! if you want to get too technical about it...! i absolutely love both players but if i were to pick one to play lb in my team then carlos would be it..! he is simply a impact player...he alone can change the course of the game with his play...and dominate the whole left wing.
besides his defensive, leadership, abilities on the back, he can run the left mid as well and in case of a free kicks from distance he can be the ultimate weapon for scoring..as well with his rocket shots..! add to that his amazing grace under pressure, winner's mentality and lovely personality you cant ask for a better player in your team..!
maldini is like the ultimate "Maytag Man" you can assign him any position on defense as coach and simply forget about any danger to your team on that front. he is the iron man of modern football and the ultimate captain...! if it werent for him i probably wouldnt like Italy all that much...! and one other plus is that his name adorns the back of my favorite jersey of all time...!
ROYAL BLUE, KAPPA ITALY JERSEY WITH ALL THE EUEFA AND ECT. PATCHES...! I USED TO LOOK SEXY AS MO FO ON THAT BIEACH....UNTIL AGE AND BEER BELLY CAUGHT UP WITH ME ...! that s.o.b is a very unforgiving jersey..

[milad]

first of all maldini can play left back right back center back he is a defender NOT an attacker rc can onl play left back. Maldinis game is not about attacking its about defending so this poll is like comparin karimi with nekounam.
and for defending no other defender can even come close to maldini
but for an attaacking defender rc is one of the best

whos better?

and youre missing the point.... this poll isnt about best defender. its about the best left back of all time.

[persiangodfather]

whos better?

and youre missing the point.... this poll isnt about best defender. its about the best left back of all time.

you know what if i had to choose a defence id use malini as CB and r c as LB but that all r c can play is lb tell him to defend as CB youll have 5 goals against this is comparing rezaei and kia

do u go and tell rezaei to take free kicks and go in the box for headers or u expect him to stay in the back and nobody gets past him

do u tell kia to stay in the center of defence and be last man back?

my point here is that maldini is not a LB he is a CB but when he plays LB for milan he never goes up this is not a good comparison at all

yes rc is better LB but maldini is better CB defender

[VivaItalia]

whats this got to do with the greatest leftback of all time vote?

For the kiddos like you to know who the legend is.