??? Is Zlatan Ibrahimovic under- oder overrated ???

[milad]

what do you mean they are "better strikers"

IMO they are different compared to Ibra. In another version of "better" Ibra is better than all of that list.

Here's my top 5 in the world at the moment:

1. Torres
2. Drogba
3. Ibra
4. Rooney
5. Van Persie

i mean better finishers. ibras role in barca is finisher so he will be ranked with them. and the fact that you do not have villa in that list means you are either high or forgot him.

[Pharaoh]

yeah and ali karimi kicked ac milan and as roma's ass and look where he's playin now sow i think aboutrika is way to overrated

You're comparing two matches (and wasn't at least one a friendly?) to titles over 5/6 years? Abou Treika is getting old anyway, so he'll probably start slowing down. I'm sure he'll gladly take an "overrated" label from you while continuing to make history for club and country with real hardware.

[K.C.I.N.]

please for god's sake dont mention Drogba in this thread

[IranSoccer#8]

ill probably get killed for this, but id say torres is overrated before id say ibrahimovic.

[Arian]

ill probably get killed for this, but id say torres is overrated before id say ibrahimovic.

ur gonna get killed because ur retarded to make such a lame comment

[chuck bass]

1.Villa
2.Torres/Zlatan
4. Rooney
5. Drogba

worlds top 5 strikers

[IranSoccer#8]

ur gonna get killed because ur retarded to make such a lame comment

i think he can score goals, but how valuable is he considering the fact he is always hurt??

[shayan20]

1.Villa
2.Torres/Zlatan
4. Rooney
5. Drogba

worlds top 5 strikers

he is def. not better than Drogba or Rooney or Torres.
He is still inconsistent and for large parts of the game goes hidden.
Maybe in top10 but definitely not a top5.

[elnino99]

ill probably get killed for this, but id say torres is overrated before id say ibrahimovic.

Of course he is over-rated
10 games in EPL so far, 10 goals
playing the last 2 games despite being injured , but still scoring CLASS goals, not tap-ins. both against United and Fulham.
How does getting injured in INTERNATIONAL DUTIES make you over-rated. Torres has neverb een injured playing for Liverpool, he goes and plays for Spain in a meaningless friendly or qualifer and gets injured. same with Gerrard

of course Torres is over-rated. He has scored in every single important game he has played for Liverpool.

vs. Chelsea 2007 in his debut @ Anfield
vs. Marsellie in 2007, dribbling 4 defenders and scoring, a must win game for Liverpool in CL, very similar to the current situation

vs. Arsenal 2008 CL, in the 4-2 game a class goal
vs. Chelsea 2008 CL, in the 3-2 loss,
vs. Chelsea 2009, 2 goals in the last 3 minutes
vs. Man U 2009, the first striker to officially own Vidic.
v.s Arsenal 2009, again, 2 goals
vs. Chelsea 2009, in the 3-1 defeat
vs. Man U 2009, 70% fit Torres totally owned Ferdinand and scored a world class goal

have scored 5 hatricks in 2 seasons and 2 months in Liverpool (and he was out for 4 months last year)




VERY VERY OVER-RATED

[milad]

he is def. not better than Drogba or Rooney or Torres.
He is still inconsistent and for large parts of the game goes hidden.
Maybe in top10 but definitely not a top5.

i thought christmas is in 2 months?

[shayan20]

he had a solid game versus mallorca, his back heel pass to pedro for the first goal was sublime and he got a penalty. his number of assists is growing quickly.

[Masoud_A]

I cant believe ppl are putting Villa at the top of list above Drogba and Zlatan.
my list
1- Drogba/Zlatan
2- Torres
3- Rooney
4- Anelka

[shayan20]

I cant believe ppl are putting Villa at the top of list above Drogba and Zlatan.
my list
1- Drogba/Zlatan
2- Torres
3- Rooney
4- Anelka

I respectly disagree with that

Zlatan will never be as good a player as Torres or Drogba or Villa. Im being honest here, he just has moments of brilliance but throughout the game he doesnt do enough running and doesnt get involved in the play as much, (maybe with more time in Barca he will do better).
Villa is underrated here. He delivers all the time for Spain and carries Valencia on his shoulders all the time if he was in a bigger team he would be in top3 fifa players.

[Masoud_A]

I respectly disagree with that

Zlatan will never be as good a player as Torres or Drogba or Villa. Im being honest here, he just has moments of brilliance but throughout the game he doesnt do enough running and doesnt get involved in the play as much, (maybe with more time in Barca he will do better).
Villa is underrated here. He delivers all the time for Spain and carries Valencia on his shoulders all the time if he was in a bigger team he would be in top3 fifa players.

He used to everything in Juventus and Inter, you for sure remember that I posted in barca fan thread when Zlatan came to barca that he wont be able to use his potential because barca already has players like messi, xavi and iniesta who do the running and dribbling and stuff and Barca only wants him to tip the ball in. back then you disagreed with me too but now you are repeating my point and again disagreeing with me?

[shayan20]

He used to everything in Juventus and Inter, you for sure remember that I posted in barca fan thread when Zlatan came to barca that he wont be able to use his potential because barca already has players like messi, xavi and iniesta who do the running and dribbling and stuff and Barca only wants him to tip the ball in. back then you disagreed with me too but now you are repeating my point and again disagreeing with me?

I remember you said he wont fit into Barca's system because of his ego and self-centric attitude and I said Pep will sort that out and he will become a team player. I was right, not only is he joint top scorer in the league with Messi, he has assisted many as well.
But when you see the whole game he goes hiding for large periods, and sometimes seems like he doesnt want the ball. thats why I think he is not as good as drogba or torres.