Who is the most OVERRATED and the most UNDERRATED Goalkeeper in today's world?

[The Joker]

Some of you saying that Casillas is overrated makes me laugh

[shayan20]

Some of you saying that Casillas is overrated makes me laugh

[persiangodfather]

Some of you saying that Casillas is overrated makes me laugh

[IranSoccer#8]

Underated-Tuncay

[PersianPrins]

cech>>over rated

valdes>>under rated.

Cech is still among the world best keepers. Valdes is in top 20 maybe, but defiently not underrated


i would say that: Julio Cesar and Casillias are is overrated. Cas can make some F*cking great saves, but the Milan match showed that he can make some mistakes too!

[kaebi kabab]

Rahmati-underrated
Cech-overrated

[Arzhang]

lol at all of you who say Casillas is overrated. You guys must not watch Madrid games regularly or are anti-laliga or something because this guy is simply incredible. Without him Madrid are in the relegation zone, lol exageration maybe, but he's that good. Not only is he without argument top 3 in the world, he is still very young and has been starting at Madrid since he was 18!!! Check out his second save in this video against Sevilla a couple weeks ago, INSANE:

For me Buffon, Julio Cesar, and Casillas are the best. lol at whoever said Valdes is overrated, since when is he rated highly??

[shayan20]

^
That save alone should make him the top goalkeeper right now.
although if a video shows his other saves both for spain and madrid people will realize he is number one.
and lol at Real relegating without him

[PersianMadrid7]

"Cech overrated"
"Casillas overrated"
"Valdes underrated"

what?!?!

All keepers make mistakes, but Valdes is a donkey, he's lucky Barcelona keep so much possession otherwise he'd be playing for Sporting Gijon.

Underated:
Akinfeev
Shay Given
Julio Cesar

Overrated:
any goalkeeper that some people here say are underrated.

[milad]

top 3 best in the world for the past while have been casillas, buffon, cesar.


underrated: diego lopez (villareals keeper).

[Arian]

actually i forgot about shay given

hes the most underrated

[chuck bass]

overrated: foster
underrated: akinfeev

[yashar_fasihnia]

over rated: cech specially ever since his injury where his form has dropped but his hype and fame still remains.

under rated: julio caesar.

[Suprah]

Helmet Boy Cech has ceased to be what he once was. I call it a crisis in confidence and an ever present fear that he will get hurt again. That is why his performance has really diminished since his unfortunate injury.

Among the under-rated ones, I would say West Ham's Robert Green is pretty under-rated because he has to deal with a horrible defence and pulls off some great saves each game. Plus he is also more or less England no.1 as well.

Paul Robinson is over-rated though.

[El-Presidente]

underraded:
Doni
Frey
Schwarzer

Overraded:
Cech
Talebloo ( cant do shit)