Red card or no?

[Shahin K]

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xnj...red-card_sport

Discuss, I'll add my thought later.

btw, I can't find that post a poll button anymore!

[Kasra.]

MAx yellow, no way its red.

[leviathan]

This kind of call is sickening! He went for the ball sliding and got it....Vincent Kompany did not go for Nani's legs.....Another sad day for football. The Referee (Chris Foy) is an Idiot.

Not even a yellow....for what?

[EKBATAN]

He ruined the game, that was NOT a red, max yellow.


Looks like city can only hope to win EPL, they're out of FA and CL.

[soniq]

tackles of such animalistic nature deserve a red.

[Kamal0098]

Althought this kind of tackling is a red card , but normally refs don't give out red cards that easy. However the ref did really shit on that day , he missed a 100% penanlty for Man U on purpose. Poor refing more like Mohsen Torki refing lol

[Ghermez Agha]

most definately not

[KasraKhan]

It's the rule, I dont agree with the rule, but I commend the referee for strictly following it.

[yashar_fasihnia]

i think its a yellow, but even if its a red, i dont understand why kompany was banned for 4 games after that!!

[oldcoach]

Good call.

[Shahin K]

I agree with most of you guys, I think not all 2 footed tackles should be threated the same. This one wasn't a dangerous one and a perfectly fine tackle as well.

[leviathan]

I didn't realize he did a two footed tackle, (even though he got the ball and didn't get Nani)......So i stand corrected, the Ref did his Job....but the rule has a problem. Not all two footed tackles are the same and are dangerous.

[persianallstars]

yellow but not red

[IranFootball10]

i feel like a red was too harsh especially since it was so early in the game as well. yellow for sure, but i don't agree with the red