Poll : Who is right?- Carlos Queiroz or Branko

[Behzad A]

I was hoping that the relationships between the coaches of the two major IPL teams (Perspolis and Esteghlal) and Carlos Queiroz helps Team Melli to have less drama. Now with what has unveiled between Branko and Carlos Queiroz it is very disappointing. Who do you think is right? Just write Carlos or Branko before explaining your position.

[kia]

Mayeligohan.

[Ab-Gosht]

TM > Clubs

[Mahyar24]

TM ofcource

Sendt fra min HTC One med Tapatalk

[AminGP]

I don't see any poll but my vote goes to TM. World cup and Asian Cup happens once every 4 years but IPL and ACL is every year so priority is always the national team.

People keep comparing Iran and our clubs to european teams and they keep saying that european clubs release their players 4 days prior to fifa day. You think that's the only thing that is comparable? Why don't you start comparing each with basic stuff like training camp, training pitch, stadiums, kits, food, club managers and trainers, recovery programs etc... I

[04041374]

1. Team Melli
....
....
....
....
2. Perspolis

[jahandoost]

Branko is a classy person, lets give it some time before we assign blame.

[maniei]

It's the same discussion as with TMs defensive style of play. And it's frustrating that it has to be explained over and over again.

If we start to play the game of all the others, we are going down!
Most other teams have better players playing in better leagues, better facilities and opportunities, better friendly games, more experience etc.
If Iran wants to achieve anything at all, we have to become more inventive than the others, instead of trying to beat others at their own game and fail.

We can't compete if we have the players only four days before the FIFA days like others! Plain and simple

[maniei]

After WC 2006 I'm once again deeply disappointed by Branko

[Team Melli Fan]

Queiroz is right, it's the international break.

[Ali Doust]

Branko is nothing but a tool of the regime. The Foreign Meyeli Kohan.

[Shah Abbas]

Branko is nothing but a tool of the regime. The Foreign Meyeli Kohan.

More evidence that the irrational support for CQ on this forum is actually (somehow!) political.

[Ghermez Agha]

As a diehard red and big fan of Branko, I must say I am appauled by his behavior. I definitely see why he could be angry, but the way he went about this was something I wouldn't even expect out of GN by threatening his own players. The lack of transparency here on CQ's end though, I must say, is wrong as well.

The news about these two camps coming up in Armenia and Austria came out during the TM camp in Macedonia, that's not enough of notice and clearly cuts into club training camps.

While TM is far more important than clubs, it still does not mean that clubs should have to constantly be without their players during the pre season, this is the time for coaches to do some experimenting and they need all their players to do that.

What makes me most mad at Branko here is that he should be giving TM players rest at this very moment in time anyway. They've had what, a week to 10 days of rest since the season concluded? That's what makes his actions not only childish and unprofessional but also spiteful and senseless.

Both have a little bit of wrong doing but what Branko did was very snake-esque. You'dve thought that a former TM coach would have a bit more understanding of the importance of the coming months for TM to prepare and to keep this sort of drama away from TM. After all, drama/hashiyeh was one of the biggest factors that deprived his TM group from reaching TM full potential

[Ando Teymourian]

As a diehard red and big fan of Branko, I must say I am appauled by his behavior. I definitely see why he could be angry, but the way he went about this was something I wouldn't even expect out of GN by threatening his own players. The lack of transparency here on CQ's end though, I must say, is wrong as well.

The news about these two camps coming up in Armenia and Austria came out during the TM camp in Macedonia, that's not enough of notice and clearly cuts into club training camps.

While TM is far more important than clubs, it still does not mean that clubs should have to constantly be without their players during the pre season, this is the time for coaches to do some experimenting and they need all their players to do that.

What makes me most mad at Branko here is that he should be giving TM players rest at this very moment in time anyway. They've had what, a week to 10 days of rest since the season concluded? That's what makes his actions not only childish and unprofessional but also spiteful and senseless.

Both have a little bit of wrong doing but what Branko did was very snake-esque. You'dve thought that a former TM coach would have a bit more understanding of the importance of the coming months for TM to prepare and to keep this sort of drama away from TM. After all, drama/hashiyeh was one of the biggest factors that deprived his TM group from reaching TM full potential

For the bold: Branko had 15 days to say something. Why wait until now? Surely he expected that the same PP players (give or take) that were in the Macedonia camp 2 weeks ago would be invited to this camp as well?

[sarbaz]

I love and respect CQ a lot more than Branko, I also consider TM above all others
I am a diehard Perspolisi
But I agree with Branko and others on this one
And believe me the clubs will corporate with TM and CQ before the Qatar match for a 2 week camp I am sure of it